The nominations are in and, while only English football’s most vehement and deluded nationalists have any complaints, the focus in England has inevitably been on the complete lack of native players on this year’s Ballon d’Or list and the relative paucity of Premier League involvement. Vive la mort.
The ‘Golden Ball’ award is now the FIFA Ballon d’Or following the decision to merge France Football‘s iconic prize with the FIFA World Player of the Year award in 2010. As a result, the award will be determined by votes from journalists (as per the previous Ballon d’Or, but now worldwide), coaches and players. The 2010 FIFA Ballon dOr award ceremony will be held in Zurich on January 10th and will see the crowning of the best player in the world, as spurious as such an honour is. Here are the nominees:
Xabi Alonso (Spain), Daniel Alves (Brazil), Iker Casillas (Spain), Cristiano Ronaldo (Portugal), Didier Drogba (Ivory Coast), Samuel Eto’o (Cameroon), Cesc Fabregas (Spain), Diego Forlan (Uruguay), Asamoah Gyan (Ghana), Andres Iniesta (Spain), Julio Cesar (Brazil), Miroslav Klose (Germany), Philipp Lahm (Germany), Maicon (Brazil), Lionel Messi (Argentina), Thomas Muller (Germany), Mesut Ozil (Germany), Carles Puyol (Spain), Arjen Robben (Holland), Bastian Schweinsteiger (Germany), Wesley Sneijder (Holland), David Villa (Spain) and Xavi (Spain).
Vital statistics
- The list include seven Spaniards, five Germans, three Brazilians, two Dutchmen and one very special Argentine
- La Liga is the most represented league (11 players), with the Bundesliga on five and Serie A with four (with only one club representing each). The Premier League has three players nominated
- Barcelona are the club with the most nominees (six), followed by Bayern Munich (five), Inter Milan and Real Madrid (both four)
- In 2010, the nominees have (I think) piled up: seven World Cups (including the winning goal), nine World Cup finals, 16 league titles, four Champions Leagues (not including the winning goals), nine Champions League finals, one Europa League, ten domestic cups, four trebles and six doubles
A quick look at who’s in
For many, the name that sticks out will be Asamoah Gyan of Sunderland and Ghana. Gyan’s inclusion on the list of nominees clearly does not give him much chance of actually winning the award and, as such, should be seen both as a deserved nod of appreciation for his phenomenal contribution to the World Cup and an indicator of just how much weight the World Cup carries in the list. It certainly plays a big part in the decision to include Diego Forlan, who had a superb tournament in South Africa in addition to a fine season for Atletico Madrid.
It also probably helped the cause of one or two of the Germans on the list, perhaps most notably Mesut Ozil and Thomas Muller, although a couple of the Bayern Munich players included made more than a few waves in club football. Carles Puyol and Iker Casillas would arguably have missed out on the list had Spain had a poor World Cup (they didn’t, so it’s immaterial), while I find Cesc Fabregas to be one of only a handful of outright curious selections.
Also on the list, of course, are the usual suspects and in particular the 2009 winner of the pre-merger awards, Lionel Messi.
A quick look at who’s out
Let’s get the Englishman out of the way early: I would have preferred to see Ashley Cole included in place of a few of the players who did make it. That’s not because he’s English and plays in the Premier League, it’s because I think the man is a magnificent footballer, albeit one that plays in a position that makes it tough to get noticed sometimes. It’s also worth giving Gerard Pique a nod, although one could argue that his 2010 wasn’t as good as 2009. Again, if Barcelona had knocked Inter out of Europe (and thanks to his goal they nearly did), Pique would’ve been nailed on.
It’s two Inter players who I think are the most surprising omissions. At the back, Lucio has been wonderful for the Nerazzurri. He was a rock throughout their treble-winning campaign and enhanced his reputation as a defender who just loves to defend and wouldn’t mind the ball being in his penalty area for 90 minutes, as demonstrated against Pique’s Barcelona. At the other end, Diego Milito doesn’t make a lot of noise but he really put his stamp on world football last season. He scored all the vital goals at the business end of the year for Inter, culminating in a typically Milito double in the Champions League final in Madrid.
A quick look at the potential winners
Here, it’s difficult to look past the Spain and Barcelona engine room. Andres Iniesta has a World Cup-winning goal in his favour and has been working in beautiful, influential tandem with Xavi in two of the year’s leading teams. Xavi’s form at times has been outrageous. Likewise their club colleague, Leo Messi, who has been in dazzling fettle for Barca and done some things that just shouldn’t be possible. And for me, Wesley Sneijder should be in with a shout. He won the treble with Inter and guided the Netherlands to an unexpected World Cup final, scoring some brilliant goals for both along the way.
When it comes down to it, I think it’s difficult to see any of these three Barcelona players missing out but I have a sneaking suspicion that one of them just might. I think it will come down to Xavi, Messi and Sneijder, with the Spaniard taking home the Ballon d’Or in January. I realise this means Iniesta gets nothing but I think it’s difficult to imagine Sneijder or Messi not in the top three this year.
Over to you. Who do you think will win it, and who do you think should?
twofootedtackle.com is trying to raise £1,000 for Cardiac Risk in the Young, which works to raise awareness of heart conditions that lead to sudden cardiac death and sudden death syndrome. You can help by donating just £2 at justgiving.com/twofootedtackle.
Tags: FIFA
Gareth Bale chaps, Gareth Bale
Next year, Tim. I’m certain of it.
Great shout Tim. But that would be forgetting Danny Rose.
I can’t for the life of me figure why Fabregas is in there. He didn’t really play at the World Cup; has been struggling with injury this season; struggled with injury last season (before having a good run of form admittedly) but there have to be more credible contenders. I’d give a shout out for the inclusion of Mr Carlos Tevez.
Gyan? You mean the guy who missed the PK?
That would be like giving it to Beckham whenever he would play the WC.
I asked a french friend how he played at Rennes and it was ‘Bof…’ which is french for ‘meh’.
And his time at Sunderland is pretty Bof! too.
So were left with 3 goals in the WC which is actually pretty good, not sure its enough to be in this select group when you realize that two were scored on PK. Or that he choked on the last one.
Eddie is right on the money. I like Cesc a lot but he doesnt belong in that list this time around. And with the last two seasons that Tevez had its a joke that he is not.
But I dont get too upset because I dont reallly care. These awards mean as much to me as who wins Idol or a beauty contest.
Its as interesting to me as when people drone on about kits and which sponsor they get to wear on their overprices jerseys.
Only award I care about is a non-objective one like best scorer.
I’m caught in two minds over who I would like to win the award and who I think will win it.
Lionel Messi has been the best player on the planet this year. Up until March it was between him and Rooney for all of the goalscoring headlines but that soon ended and Messi rose to a level of his own. His constant brilliance at club level for Barcelona will probably draw a lot of votes from coaches, captains and journalists that maybe don’t spend a lot of time watching European football. Messi has been the headlines grabber for Barca and didn’t have a bad World Cup even though Argentina were pretty poor. It wasn’t a great World Cup; but it wasn’t terrible. And that’s why he will probably win the voting.
Of course, I’d like to see Xavi win it. He passed Spain to the World Cup and is very often the man that feeds Messi and allows him to take all the attention. There isn’t a more rounded midfielder going right now. He just strides onto a pitch and bosses the game and I would love to see him get the award as it will be a shame for his career if he never wins it. Much like Raul never winning it as he was always consistently nominated but never on the tip of people’s tongues, it would be a shame that Xavi doesn’t get the title at least one year. Plus, he dragged his team to the World Cup; that’s got to count for something.
The yardstick use in judging who will be the Ballon d’or should not be only world cup performance,we all watch both the leagues and wc,observing that some factors can contribute 2 any player’s failure. MY REASON IS SOME NOMINEES KNOWS THAT SOME ARE FAR MORE BETER THAN THEM.FOR INSTANCE,(XABI CAN’T COMPARE WITH XAVI).NOW CONSIDER LEAGUE PERFORMANCE AND FABULOUSLY PLAYED FOOTBALL we have only 3 out of 23 names,THEY ARE
C RONALDO, MESSI AND XAVI.BUT BASE ON THE 2009/10 PERFORMANCE, MESSI (MAGICIAN) IS THE BEST PLAY ON EARTH.FOLLOWED BY XAVI………….