37-year-old Ryan Giggs will this season win his 12th Premier League title. He’s played over 800 games for Manchester United, over 60 for Wales and has collected an impossibly large array of team and personal honours during his remarkable career. In January, United fans voted him the club’s greatest ever player. It’s a credit to him that even in a club that has been graced by Bobby Charlton, George Best, Duncan Edwards, Eric Cantona and countless others, few would argue with the Welshman’s place at the top table.
Just so you know, there’s nothing new in the post, nor is there anything original. But just like many media titles - amateur, professional and those that inexplicably employ Oliver Holt - this site has carried such a paucity of praise for Giggs that it’s only right to redress the balance. Given the length of time for which he’s been at the top and the number of gongs atop his bowing mantelpiece, there will be a time when football will look back on Giggs’ career and ask the big question: Was he one of the very best of all time? For me he’s a distance off that, but I don’t think it’s wrong to consider it a possibility.
Giggs has been a permanent fixture in the Premier League, beginning as a much-hyped teenager and evolving into one of its elder statesmen during the twilight of his career. Whatever you think of the Premier League and its influence on the game, Giggs’ impact has been an enormous part of it and he can’t be held responsible for the prism through which cynics and traditionalists will scrutinise his career. In those early days he was apart from the crowd, football’s latest “first superstar”, as he became the selling point for the game’s new dawn. Ryan Giggs Soccer Skills was a popular choice of viewing for children in between their weekend training and matches, and the player was easily exciting enough to justify the attention placed upon him.
17 years after that show’s run, Giggs is still at Old Trafford and still putting in the type of performance that creates hyperbolic proclamations that the current season is his best ever. While I don’t necessarily agree with the specific sentiment, the fact that respected football figures like Martin Tyler are willing to ask with a straight face whether it might be the case speaks volumes. Giggs is consistent, well-respected and occasionally electric, and he’s got the medals to prove his worth.
To date, Giggs has won 11 Premier League titles, two Champions Leagues, four FA Cups and four League Cups, making him the most successful player in the rich history of English football. In 2009, Giggs finally won the PFA Player of the Year Award, adding the honour to an already lengthy list of personal triumphs. In truth, it wasn’t really the right year for it and perhaps was a collective admission from the players that Giggs had been shamefully overlooked on a few occasions in the previous decade.
Giggs’ quality has rarely dipped below excellent. As a young player he would dance up the wing at pace and he became one of the league’s most potent threats. He probably would have scored a few more goals too, if he hadn’t been behind Denis Irwin, David Beckham and Cristiano Ronaldo in various set piece pecking orders. 12 league titles (probably) and two (so far) Champions League triumphs on, Giggs has arguably become a much more rounded player. He is not just at home in a more central role, he’s superb there. He has an influence on the tempo of matches. His passing - though not necessarily spectacular - is perfectly weighted and blessed with his vision. His legs might not be as fast as they were but his creativity has improved tenfold, and he’s been adaptable enough to be an important part of the best team in the country as he heads into his late 30s.
It’s often said of Paul Scholes that he’s one of the last of the old school, a throwback to a less glamourous age when the footballers did their talking on the pitch and in the pub, and were more likely to retain some grasp of their roots. Like Scholes, Giggs has spent years at the very top of the game and yet has managed to avoid most of the other nonsense that goes on around it. Despite the talent at his disposal, Giggs hasn’t sought a big money move to Real Madrid, or amassed hundreds of thousands of pounds in parking fines, or launched a fragrance. There is no ‘Brand Giggsy’ and in an age in which top footballers are taking ever-increasing strides away from the supporters that make it all possible, there’s a lot to be said for players who generally just keep their heads down and be quietly brilliant for years on end. They’re still not like us, as such, but at least they’re on the same planet.
I suppose that leads us on to why Giggs, despite the trophies and the personal accolades, probably won’t be remembered alongside the likes of Diego Maradona, Pele, Alfredo di Stefano, Zinedine Zidane and the all-time greats, or even someone like Lionel Messi. It would be wrong to suggest that Giggs isn’t skillful, because he is, and the assuredness and accuracy behind his execution of the simple things is beyond what the overwhelming majority of his peers can do. But he isn’t always spectacular, and that might well hold him back in the collective memory. If anything, Giggs is a player’s player, a pundit’s player. The educated eye sees the importance of his contributions and just how talented a player he is, but there are many football fans around the world to whom the 30-yard screamer or the backheel pass will always be more impressive than a laser-guided ball out wide or just keeping the play moving for one of the best teams in the world.
Of course, Giggs also suffers from the George Best factor, namely being absolutely sodding brilliant but playing for a country with a limited chance of playing in major championships, let alone winning them. For many to consider Messi an equal of Maradona, he’ll have to win the World Cup even if he has to do it single-handedly. Giggs, like Best before him, essentially entirely lacks the international dimension to any discussion on world greats, and it’s a significant handicap.
But when all is said and done, and the Welshman finally hangs up his boots, he definitely won’t be underappreciated. In the final years of his incredible career we seem to finally be getting it, and it’s about time.
Tags: Manchester United, Ryan Giggs
For me, I know a lot of people have (somewhat justifiably) criticised Giggs for picking and choosing when he turned out for Wales, but the reason I still love him is, depsite this, he was still an absolute icon and inspiration for those of us who happened to support Wales and were growing up as he was starting his career.
There was also no doubt that Giggs was one of the best players ever to pull on the Welsh shirt (not the best, that would be John Charles, obviously) and was a great leader and inspiration. He was the gel and level head that nearly saw Wales through to the Euros in 2004 (even if other players took the limelight for this - yes, I’ll always love Craig Bellamy for that goal against Italy).
A true legend of the modern era, regardless of the team you support, and for the Welsh, a man to be very proud of indeed.
Trivia question: for whom in the 1990s did Ryan Giggs once score a goal while wearing a green-and-black-striped shirt? And no, it wasn’t one of the 839 Man Utd away kits that you’ve forgotten…
In the ‘modern era’ - and I suppose I mean since the advent of the Premier League which happily(?) coincided with the start of Giggs’ amazing career - there is no-one to stand up to Ryan Giggs in all round footballing terms.
Better players, yes, better men, no. Longevity and loyalty are often overlooked attributes in football. Nice to see you’re recognising them alongside his abilities, Chris.
Without doubt my favourite footballer of all time and I don’t see that being changed by anyone playing the game currently.
Quick one to Gary Andrews - you must be the only person on the planet to ‘love’ Craig Bellamy! And yes, I include his mother in that. ;o)
Maybe I’ve got this wrong, but isn’t it true that Giggs has never received a red card? Given the number of games he’s played, that matters.
You see players in their early 30s and notice their legs going. Giggs is pushing 40 and is seems to be getting better.
Sorry Ben but keep your praise for his athletic feats: praising him as a man has proven to be foolish.
He might be a great man on the field but he has proven that off the field he is no better than Rooney, Crouch or Cole.
As a ‘man’, he is a fallible as any of us.
Giving him that farce of an award last year when he barely played was based on his off field qualities as much as his on field ones and thats why I have no problems when Rooney and company do things that bring their morals and character in question, its when the on field image is helped by a (false) off field one that I draw the line.
This moral superiority is part of the package of the Giggs Brand.
I think the Sunday Herald has finally burst that bubble.
Find another word besides loyalty to describe him.
Terrific competitor.
Fine athlete.
Just keep the moral values out of the equation: he has lost the right to use them.
Right now he is to be judged like Rooney will be: on talent alone. And I see nothing wrong with that. That is the only thing we have to judge players by.
All the other talk about mental makeup and qualities is meaningless.
Like so many great players, you can be a great footballer and not be a great man.